Melinda A. Schumaker is an Associate in the Firm's Professional Liability Defense Practice Group. She specializes in the defense of healthcare systems, hospitals, physicians, and nurses in complex medical professional liability litigation. She accepts and handles cases directly assigned to her by clients and provides senior associate level assistance to multiple established partners.
Ms. Schumaker handles all aspects of cases from their initiation to their successful resolution. She second chairs trials, binding arbitrations, and complex mediations; independently handles no-pay mediations; deposes plaintiffs and fact witnesses; prepares and presents witnesses for their depositions; collaborates with and retains expert witnesses; argues and prepares motions and preliminary objections; manages multifaceted discovery; completes pleadings; and conducts initial interviews of physicians and nurses.
In 2020, Ms. Schumaker was named by her peers as a Pennsylvania Super Lawyer Rising Star in the category of Medical Malpractice. For information about these selections and an overview of common third-party publications, rankings, and lists methodologies, click here.
Prior to joining Post & Schell, P.C. in 2008, Ms. Schumaker practiced in the Health Care Litigation and Risk Management Department of a major mid-Atlantic law firm. In that position, Ms. Schumaker served as a litigator assisting in defending medical professional liability lawsuits and as an advisor dedicated to preventing additional lawsuits. This latter aspect of her practice involved both pre-litigation handling of potential claims and claims reduction by identifying and mitigating liability risk and enhancing patient safety and quality of care.
From September 2005 to September 2006, Ms. Schumaker served as a judicial law clerk to the Honorable James P. Cullen of the Court of Common Pleas of Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Judge Cullen presided over medical professional liability cases, giving Ms. Schumaker the unique opportunity to participate in these matters from the court’s vantage point and to learn the judicial perspective on key legal issues.
Read full bio >
Read less >
- Independently represented and obtained a dismissal with prejudice for a hospital in a Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County case involving claims that an orthopedic surgeon (who was represented by separate counsel) had a private office inside of the hospital, held privileges at the hospital, and negligently performed an ankle surgery on the plaintiff at the hospital. Economic damages alone were alleged to have exceeded $1.2 million, plus pain and suffering, and loss of consortium.
- Second chaired a jury trial to a unanimous defense verdict in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County for a hospital and one of its thoracic surgeons in a case involving allegations that a woman, who underwent a surgical biopsy that was complicated by a pulmonary artery injury, had a protracted hospital course and death.
- Second chaired a jury trial to a defense verdict in the Court of Common Pleas of Montgomery County for an anesthesiologist in a case involving allegations that the anesthesiologist perforated the patient’s upper esophagus, causing the need for a right thoracotomy, as well as other surgeries.
- Worked with lead counsel to obtain a defense verdict in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County for a gastroenterologist and his practice group in a case involving allegations of a failure to properly treat gastrointestinal symptoms and of an alleged unnecessary surgical placement of a jejunal feeding tube, leading to the development of reflex sympathetic dystrophy (RSD) syndrome/complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS).
- Worked with lead counsel to obtain a defense verdict in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County for an obstetrician and his practice group in a case involving allegations that the obstetrician misdiagnosed a lack of cardiac activity, a fact consistent with fetal demise, when over one hour later a fetal heart rate was observed, leading to an emergency cesarean section and the birth of an infant with a hypoxic ischemic brain injury.
- Assisted lead counsel to secure the dismissal of eight physicians and to reach a settlement on behalf of a hospital for a nominal amount in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County in a case involving an alleged failure to timely diagnose and treat ovarian cancer.
- Assisted lead counsel in obtaining a defense verdict in the Court of Common Pleas of Philadelphia County for a hospital in a case involving an alleged failure to properly treat decubitus ulcers.
- "Fall Precautions and Documentation," Mock Trial Presentation, Nursing Symposium, Holy Redeemer Hospital and Medical Center (May 2016)
- "The Importance of Documentation," Mock Trial Presentation, Nursing Symposium, Holy Redeemer Hospital and Medical Center (November 2011)